Opening range breakout, EMA crossovers, Supertrend and CPR are some of the most shared intraday strategies in India — in videos, reels and Telegram groups. They usually come with a few clean example charts. We wanted the full picture, so we ran each one, exactly as it is usually taught, on every trading day from 1 July to 2 November 2026 (86 sessions) across all 218 NSE F&O stocks, using 1-minute prices, and counted every trade — winners and losers — after charges.
The results
Every trade risked the same ₹1,000 (the gap between entry and stop-loss × quantity), so the strategies can be compared fairly.
| Strategy | Trades | Profitable | Avg before charges | Avg after charges |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Opening range breakout (15 min) | 11,788 | 42.8% | +₹22 | −₹104 |
| 9/21 EMA crossover + VWAP | 14,570 | 38.7% | +₹15 | −₹147 |
| Supertrend (10, 3) flip | 4,000 | 38.1% | −₹8 | −₹161 |
| Narrow CPR breakout | 2,359 | 33.3% | −₹16 | −₹190 |
What the numbers say
- None of the four made money after charges. Across 32,717 trades, the average trade lost between ₹104 and ₹190.
- Charges decide it. Before charges, opening range breakout (+₹22) and the EMA crossover (+₹15) were roughly break-even. Brokerage, STT, exchange fees, GST, stamp duty and a small slippage allowance cost ₹126–174 per trade at these sizes — more than any strategy earned.
- Most trades lose. Only 33–43% of trades were profitable. With a 1:2 target that sounds enough on paper, but charges on every trade push the break-even point higher.
- One good month is not a strategy. Opening range breakout made +₹73 per trade in October — and lost ₹188 per trade in July. A few weeks of screenshots can make any of these look great.
This matches the bigger picture: SEBI's study of FY26 found that about 88% of individual F&O traders lost money, and options accounted for most of those losses.
Why they look so good online
- Hand-picked examples. A chart where the breakout worked is easy to find on any day. The many that failed are not shown.
- No charges. Most examples count points, not rupees after costs. Our test shows that is exactly where the money goes.
- Hindsight. On a finished chart the "right" signal is obvious. In real time, a real breakout and a false one look the same.
Before you try any strategy
- Test it on at least 3 months of data, every trade, not just examples — and include charges.
- Fix your risk per trade (for example 1% of capital) and size the quantity from your stop-loss, so one trade cannot hurt badly.
- Set a daily loss limit and stop for the day when you reach it.
- Keep a journal. Write down every trade and the reason. After a few weeks it shows what actually works for you and what does not.
- Check your costs with a brokerage calculator — small, frequent trades lose the most to charges.
How we tested
- Data: NSE 1-minute prices, 218 F&O stocks, 1 July – 2 November 2026 (86 sessions), grouped into 5-minute candles.
- Opening range breakout: high and low of 9:15–9:30; first 5-minute close beyond it (until 11:00); stop at the other side; target 2× risk.
- EMA crossover + VWAP: 9 EMA crosses the 21 EMA on 5-minute candles, price on the same side of VWAP (9:30–14:00); stop at the last 30-minute swing; target 2× risk.
- Supertrend (10, 3): first flip after 9:45 (until 14:00); stop at the Supertrend line; target 3× risk.
- Narrow CPR: days when the central pivot range was under 0.25% wide; first 5-minute candle that crosses out of it (until 11:30); stop at the other side; target 2× risk.
- For all: one trade per stock per day, ₹1,000 risk per trade, position at most ₹1.5 lakh, trades without a target or stop closed at 15:15. Charges: ₹20 brokerage per order, STT, exchange fees, GST, stamp duty, plus 0.05% for slippage.
Limits of this test
We tested the common textbook version of each strategy. Traders change the settings, time windows and exits, and another period or other stocks can give different results. Past results do not tell you what will happen next. This page is education only — it is not investment advice or a recommendation to trade or avoid any strategy.